THE LONG SONG by ANDREA LEVY

Right. Bear with me. This is a difficult one to review. The reason for that is because at times I really disliked this book - worse: I found it boring. However, at other times I was completely gripped and in love with the characters and their journeys.

Sigh.

Alas, my overall reading experience was not a positive one. I wanted to DNF many times but my enjoyment of the “good bits” prevented me from doing so.

So, the story is about Jamaica slightly before, during and after the end of slavery. The main character is July and she is the daughter of a slave and a white man; the product of rape. She works for an Englishman and his sister in their plantation house.

Alongside that storyline, we have the present day, wherein a woman named July is writing this story under the watchful eye of her son Thomas. I found that Thomas was an irrelevant character in the present day as was the entire present-day storyline. Maybe I missed the point.

What I found interesting was learning about slavery in Jamaica. I also found interesting, as I always do in literature, human nature. Racism has always baffled me. I remember learning about Martin Luther King as a child and being completely flabbergasted that people could be treated differently because of how they look. I never understood it. I still don’t really. But since then I have read as much as I could to try understand what it is about us humans that makes us behave this way. This book does shine a light on some of that. And mostly the answer is fear. Isn’t that what motivates most of our hideous actions?

Well, you can probably see how perplexed I am. I rarely write long reviews. I can normally tell you straight away what I love or dislike about a book, but this one is troubling. I think it had all the ingredients to be my favourite but it didn’t quite work for me. But why? Is it because the story wasn’t as predictable as I was expecting? I don’t know. I think I’ll go and eat some breakfast and see if that helps to unscramble my thoughts.
Has anyone else read this book and had a similar or completely different experience? Let me know! It might help!

Comments

BONJOUR TRISTESSE / A CERTAIN SMILE by FRACOISE SAGAN

BONJOUR TRISTESSE by FRACOISE SAGAN French Literature at its finest. There are actually two novels in this book and Bonjour Tristesse is the first and that is the one I’ll review first. The novella (100 pages) takes place over a summer on the French Riviera. Cecile and her father have rented the villa for two months to escape from the heat of Paris. Her widowed father brings with him his young and beautiful mistress, but then another guest turns up... The star of this book, though, is the setting. The French Riviera. The beach. The glistening ocean. The sailing. The sex. The sun. The wine. The cigarettes. The sadness that only comes with being seventeen and in love, or not in love. I just can’t get over the fact that the author was 18 when she wrote this. A CERTAIN SMILE by FRACOISE SAGAN Well, well, well, I had no idea that I could love the second novella more than the first. What an exquisite story. I felt like I was reading a French Sally Rooney. It is very much like Conversati...

ANOTHER BROOKLYN by JACQUELINE WOODSON

ANOTHER BROOKLYN by JACQUELINE WOODSON I read this book in the space of a few hours and as soon as I finished I turned back to the first page again. I didn’t read it all again - just that first page and it worked. It’s a cyclical book. It doesn’t need to be read in any particular order. Memories manifest in any way they want to. This book is a series of memories told from the point of view of August; a teenager growing up in Brooklyn in the 1970s. She states early on in the book that life would have been different if she’d known about jazz, but all she knew of was the top 40 (white artists mostly). And “it never quite figured us out.” I found that one statement to be huge! It’s a 170 page novel, but that statement to me felt bigger than the messages I’ve taken from 1000 page novels. If we can’t see ourselves represented, how can we see ourselves at all? My own white privilege means that this is something I rarely have to think about, but this book helped me to understand how that...

THE EIGHTH LIFE by NINO HARATISCHVILI

THE EIGHTH LIFE by NINO HARATISCHVILI I have been reading this book for a month (since @scribe_uk started their read-along) and in that time these characters have become part of my life. I feel like I have lived with their stories for so long that I have become part of their family. This book is the definition of epic. It is 944 pages long (the longest book I’ve ever read) and it spans over 100 years of Georgian history; living under Tsar rule, WWI, The October Revolution, Lenin, Stalin, WWII, all the way up to the fall of the Soviet Union and 2007 political demonstrations. In that time I relearned my intrigue for Soviet history, I fell in love with the Jashi and Eristravi families and I craved chocolate more than ever before. If you haven’t read this then you probably should and if you have read this, please comment with your favourite character(s). I think mine would have to be Christine or Stasia or Kitty. But honestly I loved them all and all their stories. I don’t think...

Libby's Bookshelf

Search This Blog